Hey Mary and Andrew,
Mary, I’m glad that you brought this up…
This is exactly what I was going for… you see, Romanian Deadlifts may not be the best option. There are so many other ways to strengthen the hip joint before doing that exercise (and, to tell you the truth, I see benefit with RDLs, but not enough for the potential of injury) in my opinion.
I’d much prefer strengthening the hip segment by segment, while working the rest of the body with as many compound movements as possible.
For example, you might consider targeting muscles in this order (again, I can’t see you, so this is just an example, not an exercise prescription):
Bridges (progress from easy to very difficult versions involving unstable surfaces and single leg stability)
Squats (emphasizing glute squeeze) – again, with focus on unstable surfaces & skill progression before resistance. This would teach someone how to squat evenly on both legs (therefore improve balance). There’s no lesson like standing on a balance board and trying to squat. Just watch which way it tips and you’ll be surprised that there’s usually a pattern. That means you are weight bearing more on that leg than the other with lower body exercises.
Sidelying ABduction – hip extended behind you, knee straight, raising top leg slowly in air with toes pointed down.
Q.L. sidebridges – like a side plank, but moving
Side Step Squat – back and forth with emphasis on single leg stance
Sumo walks – front, back, rotational
Then, and only then, would I try something like a RDLs. …and, again, I’d rather do Bent-Leg Deadlifts any day.
Hope this info is helpful – sounds like you are the right kind of candidate for http://LiftHardPlayHard.com – no pressure, but just thought you should at least know I go into a LOT more detail there if you’re interested at any point.
…oh yeah, and I really like philosophy too – just wasn’t sure who else wanted to learn about famous philosophers over fitness
Andrew – i’m not sure I understand the question. Can you please be more specific when you mention ‘lifting a single weight’?
Thanks!